Shift 25 · Rules · Systems

Treaties turning from obligation to option

DeteriorationEmerging

From treaties and memberships as lasting obligations to commitments a state can leave at will.

The evidence

In January 2026 the United States announced its withdrawal from 66 international organisations, conventions and treaties, 31 of them United Nations entities. This rests on one actor so far.

Source: American Society of International Law and International Bar Association

Supporting the shift

Four series that should each move in the shift’s direction.

Supports

Treaty withdrawals and denunciations per year

Exits should be rising if commitments are becoming optional

Supports

WTO rulings appealed with no body to hear them

Unresolved appeals have accumulated since 2019

Supports

Member states paying UN dues in full and on time

Late and partial payment has grown

Supports

States parties to the International Criminal Court

Withdrawals have been announced by several members

Not yet chartedOpen the data at ICC

Contesting the shift

Two series that complicate or limit it, chosen as the strongest objections.

Contests

Regional trade agreements entering into force

New binding agreements are still being concluded

Contests

Cases filed at the International Court of Justice

States are bringing more disputes to court, not fewer

Not yet chartedOpen the data at ICJ

0 of this shift’s 6 series are drawn from published figures. The others give their argument and link to where the data is kept.

Also in Rules

  1. 23Rule of law giving way to discretion
  2. 24Autocracies overtaking democracies