Shift 23 · Rules · Systems

Rule of law giving way to discretion

Deterioration

From power exercised within legal limits to power exercised at the discretion of those who hold it.

The evidence

The rule of law declined in 62 per cent of countries in 2026, the ninth consecutive year in which decliners outnumbered improvers, and the courts' ability to limit government weakened in 63 per cent.

Source: World Justice Project, via the Law Society of Ireland and Bianet

Supporting the shift

Four series that should each move in the shift’s direction.

Supports

Share of countries with a falling rule of law score

Decliners have outnumbered improvers for nine years

Supports

Constraints on government powers score

The factor has fallen in most countries

Supports

Judicial constraints on the executive

The global average is falling

Supports

Share of people living in closed or repressed civic space

Civic freedoms are narrowing

Contesting the shift

Two series that complicate or limit it, chosen as the strongest objections.

Contests

Corruption Perceptions Index, global average

The average has been flat for more than a decade, not falling

Contests

Rule of law index since 1900

The long-run level is still above that of the 1980s

0 of this shift’s 6 series are drawn from published figures. The others give their argument and link to where the data is kept.

Also in Rules

  1. 24Autocracies overtaking democracies
  2. 25Treaties turning from obligation to option