Shift 34 · Trade · Systems
Mineral sourcing shifting from price to security
Deterioration
From inputs bought wherever they are cheapest to inputs treated as a security question.
The evidence
The top refining country's average share of key energy minerals (excluding rare earths) rose from 70 per cent in 2023 to 72 per cent in 2025, and export controls have turned that concentration into real disruption.
Supporting the shift
Four series that should each move in the shift’s direction.
Supports
Top refiner's share by mineral
Refining has become more concentrated, not less
Supports
Export restrictions on raw materials
The number of controls has grown several-fold
Supports
China's share of rare earth production
One country dominates supply
Supports
Mineral demand from clean energy technologies
Demand is rising with electrification
Contesting the shift
Two series that complicate or limit it, chosen as the strongest objections.
Contests
Lithium, cobalt and nickel prices
Prices fell far below their 2022 peaks, which signals ample supply
Contests
Top producer's share of lithium mining
Mining, unlike refining, is diversifying
0 of this shift’s 6 series are drawn from published figures. The others give their argument and link to where the data is kept.